Magnet Media®agency

What should contractors pay for a lead?

Contractors get pitched leads from every direction: marketplaces, ad platforms, directories and agencies. Each one quotes a price per lead, and it is hard to know which are good deals. The answer depends less on the price tag and more on what each lead is worth to your business. Here is how to work that out.

5 min read · Updated October 21, 2026

A lead is not a job

The first thing to remember is that a lead is only a chance at a job. Some leads book. Many do not. When comparing lead sources, the number that matters is not what a lead costs, but what a booked job costs.

Two lead sources can look like this:

  • One sells cheap leads, but they are shared with several contractors and few of them book with you.
  • Another costs more per lead, but the homeowner contacted only you, and a much higher share of them become jobs.

The second source can easily be the better deal, even though the price per lead looks higher.

Work out what a job is worth

Start with your own numbers. For your main type of job:

  • What is the typical invoice?
  • After materials, labour and other direct costs, what profit is left?
  • Do customers tend to come back or refer others? If so, a customer is worth more than one job.

This tells you how much you can afford to spend to win a job and still come out ahead.

Know your closing rate by source

Your closing rate is how many leads turn into booked jobs. It often varies a lot by source:

  • Referrals usually close at a high rate, because the customer already trusts you.
  • Your own website and Google listing tend to close well, because the customer chose you after seeing your reviews and work.
  • Direct ads, such as Google search ads that send people to your site, often close well if the landing page is strong.
  • Shared leads from marketplaces often close at a much lower rate, because several contractors are competing for the same homeowner.

Track this for each source. Even a rough count over a few months tells you a lot.

Putting it together

Once you know what you can afford to spend per job and your closing rate for a source, you can work out the most you can pay per lead from that source:

Maximum cost per lead = what you will spend to win a job × closing rate for that source

If a source's leads cost less than that, it is profitable. If they cost more, it is losing you money, no matter how good the price per lead sounds.

Shared leads versus exclusive leads

Shared leads, sold to several contractors at once, have some advantages. They can fill gaps quickly and require little setup. But they come with downsides:

  • You compete on speed, often calling within minutes alongside others.
  • Homeowners are often overwhelmed by calls and pick whoever is cheapest or first.
  • Your closing rate tends to be lower.
  • You are building someone else's platform, not your own reputation.

Exclusive leads, from your own website, Google listing and ads, take more effort to build but usually close at a higher rate and give you more control. Our guide on getting more roofing leads explains how to build that pipeline.

Pay-per-lead ads and pay-per-click ads

Google offers two main ad types for contractors:

  • Local Services Ads charge per lead, appear at the top of Google and often carry a verification badge.
  • Search ads charge per click and send people to your website.

Pay-per-lead sounds simpler, but you still need to compare the cost per booked job, not just the cost per lead. With search ads, your landing page heavily affects how many clicks become leads. We compare them in more detail in our guide on Local Services Ads versus Search ads.

How to lower your real cost per job

There are two ways to lower the cost of winning a job: pay less per lead, or close more of the leads you get. Often the second is easier.

Close more leads

  • Respond within minutes. Speed is one of the biggest factors in winning jobs, especially for urgent work.
  • Follow up more than once. Many homeowners do not answer the first call.
  • Send quotes quickly and make them easy to understand.
  • Show proof, like reviews, photos and warranties, during the sales process.

Get better leads

  • Improve your landing page so more clicks become calls. See our guide on why ads are not converting.
  • Target the right services and areas, so you are not paying for jobs you do not want.
  • Use negative keywords to block irrelevant searches.
  • Build reviews, which help with both visibility and closing.

Seasonality matters

Lead costs often rise during peak seasons, when every contractor is advertising. At the same time, homeowners are more ready to buy. Many contractors find it worth paying more per lead in peak season, then pulling back or shifting to planned work in quieter months. Track costs by season so you know what to expect.

Keep a simple lead log

You do not need fancy software to start. A shared spreadsheet or the notes in your job management app is enough. For every lead, record:

  • The date and where it came from.
  • The service they asked about.
  • Whether you reached them, and how quickly.
  • Whether you quoted the job.
  • Whether they booked, and the job value.

After a couple of months, sort by source. You will see which channels bring jobs, which bring tyre-kickers and which bring work you do not want. Many contractors discover that a source they thought was great is mostly bringing small jobs, or that one they were about to cancel is quietly producing their biggest projects.

This log also makes conversations with anyone running your ads much more productive, because you can talk about booked jobs instead of guessing.

The short version

For contractors, the price of a lead matters less than the cost of a booked job. Work out what a job is worth, track your closing rate by source and calculate the most you can pay per lead from each one. Shared leads can fill gaps, but exclusive leads from your own website, Google listing and ads usually close better. Faster follow-up and better landing pages are often the cheapest ways to lower your real cost per job.

Quick answers

What is a good cost per lead for contractors?

It depends on what a job is worth to you and how many leads from a given source turn into jobs. Multiply what you will spend to win a job by your closing rate for that source, and that is the most you can pay per lead.

Are shared contractor leads worth it?

They can fill gaps quickly, but because several contractors compete for the same homeowner, they usually close at a lower rate. Compare the cost per booked job, not just the price per lead.

How can contractors lower their cost per lead?

Improve the landing page, target the right services and areas, block irrelevant searches with negative keywords and build reviews. Responding faster also lowers your real cost per job by closing more leads.

Are Google Local Services Ads cheaper than search ads for contractors?

Not necessarily. Local Services Ads charge per lead and search ads charge per click. The right comparison is the cost per booked job from each, which depends on your area, services and how well you handle leads.

Related services
Google Ads →Meta Ads →Landing Pages →
Keep reading
AdsWhat is a good cost per lead?AdsGoogle Local Services Ads vs Search ads: which should trades use?TradesHow to get more roofing leads without buying shared ones