Magnet Media®agency

Google Local Services Ads vs Search ads: which should trades use?

If you run a trade or home service business, you have probably seen both kinds of Google ads: the ones at the very top with a "Google Screened" or "Google Guaranteed" badge, and the regular text ads below them. They work quite differently. This guide explains how each one works and how to decide where your money should go.

5 min read · Updated October 21, 2026

What Local Services Ads are

Local Services Ads, often called LSAs, appear at the very top of Google for many service searches, such as "plumber near me" or "roof repair." They usually show a business name, star rating, a badge and a button to call or message.

A few things make them different:

  • You pay per lead, not per click. You are charged when a customer contacts you through the ad, such as a call or message, rather than when someone clicks.
  • Businesses go through verification. Google checks things like licences, insurance and, in many cases, background checks before ads can run. The badge signals this to customers.
  • Reviews matter a lot. Your rating and number of reviews strongly affect how often you appear.
  • There is no website click in most cases. Customers usually call or message directly from the ad.
  • You have less control. You choose services and areas, set a budget and can dispute leads that are clearly not valid, but you cannot write ad copy or choose keywords the way you can with regular ads.

Availability, eligible categories and verification rules vary by country and industry, so check what applies to your business.

What Google Search ads are

Regular search ads are the text ads that appear above and below the organic results. You choose keywords, write the ads and decide where clicks go.

Key features:

  • You pay per click, whether or not the person contacts you.
  • You control the details: keywords, negative keywords, ad text, landing pages, schedules and bidding.
  • Clicks go to your website or landing page, which means the quality of that page strongly affects results.
  • No verification badge, although you can show reviews, phone numbers and other extensions.

How they compare

Cost structure

LSAs charge per lead. Search ads charge per click. With search ads, if your landing page converts poorly, you pay for clicks that never turn into calls. With LSAs, you mostly pay when someone actually reaches out, although not every lead will be a good one.

Control

Search ads give you far more control. You can target specific services, block irrelevant searches, test different messages and send people to pages built to convert. LSAs are simpler but more of a black box.

Visibility

LSAs usually sit at the very top, above everything else, which is prime position. Search ads appear just below them.

Trust

The verification badge on LSAs can reassure customers, especially for services where they are letting someone into their home.

Effort

LSAs need less ongoing management once set up, though you still need to respond to leads quickly, manage reviews and dispute bad leads. Search ads need ongoing work to manage keywords, budgets, ads and landing pages.

When Local Services Ads tend to work well

  • Urgent services where people call quickly, such as plumbing, HVAC, locksmiths and garage door repair.
  • Businesses with strong reviews, since rating heavily influences how often you show.
  • Owners who want simplicity and do not have time to manage detailed campaigns.
  • Businesses that answer the phone reliably. Response time and how you handle leads can affect performance.

When Search ads tend to work well

  • Specific, higher-value services you want to target, such as water heater replacement, panel upgrades or roof replacements.
  • When you have a strong landing page that turns clicks into calls.
  • When you want more control over targeting, messaging and timing.
  • When LSAs are not available or do not cover the services you want.
  • When you need to scale beyond what LSAs can deliver.

Using both together

Many trade businesses run both. LSAs capture urgent, high-intent callers at the top of the page, while search ads target specific services, specific areas and the searches LSAs do not cover. Together they give you more presence on the page and more ways to win the customer.

If you run both, track results separately. Look at cost per lead and, more importantly, how many leads from each turn into paying jobs.

Getting the most out of Local Services Ads

  • Build your reviews. This is one of the biggest factors in how often you show.
  • Answer every call. Missed calls hurt both the lead and your performance.
  • Respond to messages quickly.
  • Choose your services and areas carefully, so you only get leads you want.
  • Dispute invalid leads, such as wrong numbers, spam or services you do not offer, using Google's process.
  • Keep your profile complete with accurate hours and details.

Getting the most out of Search ads

  • Focus on high-intent keywords combined with your services and area.
  • Use negative keywords to block jobs, DIY, supplies and other irrelevant searches.
  • Send clicks to matching landing pages, not your homepage.
  • Track calls and forms so you know what is working.
  • Adjust budgets seasonally and around weather events where relevant.

Our guide on why ads get clicks but no customers covers the landing page side in detail.

Reviews connect everything

Whichever ad type you use, reviews play a big role. For Local Services Ads, your rating and review count strongly affect how often you appear. For search ads, review extensions and the reviews people see on your Google Business Profile influence whether they trust you enough to call.

Building a steady stream of reviews from real customers improves both. A simple system works best: after every job, send a short text with a direct link to leave a Google review. Reply to every review, good or bad.

Our guide on getting more Google reviews covers scripts and timing in detail. It is one of the cheapest ways to make every advertising dollar work harder.

The short version

Local Services Ads charge per lead, sit at the very top, carry a trust badge and are simpler to run, but give you less control. Search ads charge per click and need a good landing page, but let you target specific services, control your messaging and scale. For many trades, LSAs are a strong place to start for urgent calls, with search ads added for specific high-value services. Running both, and tracking which leads turn into jobs, usually gives the best results.

Quick answers

Are Google Local Services Ads worth it for contractors?

Often yes, especially for urgent services like plumbing, HVAC and garage door repair. They charge per lead and appear at the top of Google, but they work best when you have strong reviews and answer calls reliably.

Do I pay for every lead with Local Services Ads?

You pay when a customer contacts you through the ad. Google has a process to dispute leads that are clearly invalid, such as spam or services you do not offer.

What is the difference between Local Services Ads and Google Ads?

Local Services Ads charge per lead, show a verification badge and offer limited control. Regular Google Search ads charge per click, send people to your website and let you control keywords, ads and landing pages.

Should I run Local Services Ads and Search ads together?

Many trade businesses do. Local Services Ads capture urgent callers at the top of the page, and Search ads target specific services and areas. Track results from each separately.

Related services
Google Ads →Landing Pages →
Keep reading
AdsMeta ads vs Google ads: which one should you run?TradesWhat should contractors pay for a lead?TradesHow plumbers can get more calls, and better ones