What is a good cost per lead?
Search for "average cost per lead" and you will find dozens of charts with confident numbers. The problem is that none of them know your prices, your profit or how good you are at closing. A lead that is far too expensive for one business is a bargain for another. Here is how to find the number that actually matters to you.
Why averages lead you astray
Two businesses in the same industry can have completely different ideal costs per lead.
Picture two renovation companies. One mostly does small bathroom refreshes. The other does full kitchen and basement renovations. Both are "renovation contractors," but a lead for the second company might be worth many times more, because the jobs are so much bigger. Paying the same per lead would be fine for one and ruinous for the other.
Averages also lump together businesses that close one in two leads with businesses that close one in ten, and campaigns that are well run with ones that are not. The number in the chart is a blend of all of that, which is why it rarely matches your reality.
The three numbers you need
To work out a good cost per lead for your business, you need three things:
- What a new customer is worth in profit. Take what a typical customer spends with you, over the time they stay, and subtract the cost of doing the work. What is left is the profit you are working with.
- How much of that profit you are willing to spend to win the customer. Some businesses are happy spending a large share to grow quickly. Others want to keep most of it.
- Your closing rate. Out of every ten people who contact you, how many become paying customers?
If you do not know your closing rate, start tracking it now. Even a rough count over a month or two is far better than a guess.
Putting it together
The formula is simple:
Maximum cost per lead = what you will spend to win a customer × your closing rate
Say you are comfortable spending a certain amount of profit to win one customer, and you close about one in four leads. That means each customer costs you four leads, so the most you can pay per lead is a quarter of what you are willing to spend per customer.
If you pay less than that per lead, the ads are profitable. If you pay more, you are losing money on each new customer, at least on the first job.
Lifetime value changes the picture
Many businesses only count the first job when working this out. That can make good leads look too expensive.
If customers tend to come back, refer friends or move onto a recurring plan, they are worth much more than their first invoice. A cleaning company that wins a client who books every two weeks for years, or an HVAC company that turns a repair call into a maintenance plan and later a replacement, can afford to pay more for each lead than the first job alone would suggest.
The safest approach is to calculate two numbers: one based on the first job only, and one based on a realistic lifetime value. Your comfortable cost per lead is somewhere between the two, depending on how confident you are that customers stick around.
Cheap leads are not always good leads
It is tempting to chase the lowest possible cost per lead. But a cheap lead that never answers the phone, wanted a service you do not offer or was only shopping on price is not cheap at all.
What you really care about is cost per customer. Two campaigns can look like this:
- Campaign A brings in lots of low-cost leads, but very few of them turn into jobs.
- Campaign B brings in fewer, more expensive leads, but a much higher share of them book.
Campaign B can easily be the more profitable one. That is why it is worth tracking which leads turn into customers, not just how many leads come in.
How to lower your cost per lead
If your cost per lead is higher than you can afford, there are usually a few places to look before giving up on ads:
- The landing page. If people click but do not call or fill out the form, the page is often the problem. A clear headline, real photos, reviews and an obvious way to get in touch can make a big difference. See our guide on why ads are not converting.
- Targeting. On Google, that means the right keywords and a solid list of negative keywords to block irrelevant searches. On Meta, it means the right area and audience.
- The offer. A clear reason to act now, such as a free inspection or a seasonal promotion, often lifts response.
- The creative. Better photos, videos and headlines usually lower costs on Meta in particular.
How to raise your closing rate
The other half of the equation is what happens after the lead comes in. Improving your closing rate makes every lead worth more, which means you can afford to pay more for them.
- Respond fast. Leads contacted within minutes are far more likely to book than leads contacted the next day.
- Follow up more than once. Many people do not answer the first call. A second call, a text and an email can recover a lot of them.
- Have a simple process. Clear quotes, clear next steps and someone who sounds like they want the job.
Raising your closing rate is often the cheapest way to make ads more profitable.
A worked example in plain words
Imagine a landscaping company. A typical new customer brings in a design-and-install project, and some of them stay on for seasonal maintenance. After materials and labour, the owner works out roughly what that first project is worth in profit, and decides they are happy to spend about a quarter of it to win the customer.
They look back at the last few months and see they close about one in five people who contact them. So each customer takes five leads. Their maximum cost per lead is one fifth of what they are willing to spend per customer.
Now they have a real target. If their ads produce leads below that number, they are making money. If not, they know whether to work on the ads, the landing page or their follow-up.
The short version
A good cost per lead is one that leaves you profitable after you account for how many leads it takes to win a customer. Work it out from your own numbers, track which leads actually become customers, and remember that a better landing page and faster follow-up can lower your real cost as much as changing the ads.
Quick answers
What is a good cost per lead for a small business?
It depends on what a customer is worth to you and how many leads you need to win one. Multiply what you are willing to spend to win a customer by your closing rate, and that gives you the most you can pay per lead and still be profitable.
Why is my cost per lead so high?
Common causes are a landing page that does not convert, broad targeting that attracts the wrong people, a weak offer or creative that does not stand out. Fixing the page where the ads send people often makes the biggest difference.
Should I focus on cost per lead or cost per customer?
Cost per customer is the number that decides whether your ads are profitable. Cost per lead is useful for day-to-day tracking, but cheap leads that never book can cost more than expensive leads that do.
How do I find my closing rate?
Count how many people contacted you over a month or two, and how many of them became paying customers. Divide customers by leads. Even a rough count is much better than guessing.