Magnet Media vs Wix vs Squarespace vs a freelancer: an honest comparison
If you are deciding how to get a website for your business, you are probably weighing a few familiar options: building it yourself on Wix or Squarespace, hiring a freelancer or working with a company like ours. We are obviously not neutral, so we will be upfront about where each option shines, including the cases where we are not the best fit.
Short answer: Wix and Squarespace are good tools for owners who want to build and manage a site themselves and have the time to do it well. A freelancer can be a good choice for a specific project if you find someone reliable. Magnet Media suits local service businesses that want a professional site built around their services, starting from $30/month, with content help, Google basics and changes handled for them, plus the option to run ads. The right choice depends on your time, skills and goals.
A quick note on fairness
This comparison is written by Magnet Media, so keep that in mind. We have tried to describe each option fairly, based on how they generally work. Website builders and their pricing change over time, so check their current plans and features directly before deciding.
Wix
Wix is a popular website builder with a drag-and-drop editor and many templates.
Strengths
- Very flexible editor, so you can place things almost anywhere.
- Lots of templates and built-in features, including booking and online store options on certain plans.
- No technical knowledge required to get started.
- You can edit the site yourself any time.
Things to consider
- You do the planning, writing, design and setup yourself.
- The flexibility can make it easy to create layouts that look good on a computer but awkward on a phone, so mobile needs checking.
- Getting the Google basics right, such as service pages, titles and descriptions, is up to you.
- Costs can grow with premium plans and add-ons.
Best for
Owners who enjoy hands-on design, have time to learn and want full control over every edit.
Squarespace
Squarespace is a website builder known for polished, design-focused templates.
Strengths
- Clean, attractive templates that look professional out of the box.
- Simpler, more structured editing than some builders, which helps keep layouts tidy.
- Good for visual businesses, such as photographers, designers and creative services.
- You can edit the site yourself.
Things to consider
- You still plan, write and set everything up yourself.
- Templates are more structured, so certain custom layouts can be harder.
- Making the site work hard for local search and lead generation takes knowledge and effort.
- Plans and add-ons affect the total cost.
Best for
Owners who want a polished, design-led site and are comfortable building and maintaining it themselves.
A freelancer
A freelancer is an independent designer or developer who builds the site for you.
Strengths
- Someone else does the building.
- Can be skilled and creative, especially if you find the right person.
- Direct contact with the person doing the work.
Things to consider
- Quality, process and pricing vary widely.
- You may still need to provide all the content.
- Ongoing changes depend on their availability.
- If they move on, it can be hard to get updates or support.
Best for
Businesses with a clear project and a trusted freelancer who has a strong track record with similar businesses.
Magnet Media
Magnet Media Agency builds websites and runs marketing for local and small businesses across Canada and the US, especially trades, home services and other service businesses.
Strengths
- Websites start from $30/month, with no large upfront bill.
- Each main service gets its own page, which helps customers and Google.
- We help with content, so you are not left with a blank page.
- Sites are built to load fast and work smoothly on phones.
- The Google basics and tracking are set up for you.
- You send us any changes and we take care of them, so there is nothing to learn or log in to.
- We also run Meta and Google ads, so the website and ads can work together.
Things to consider
- You do not edit the site yourself. If you want to make every change personally, a website builder may suit you better.
- We focus on local and service businesses. If you need a large online store with many products or custom software, a different provider may be a better fit.
Best for
Local service businesses that want a professional, fast site that brings in customers, without spending their own time building and maintaining it.
Side-by-side comparison
| Factor | Wix | Squarespace | Freelancer | Magnet Media |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who builds it | You | You | Freelancer | Us |
| Content writing | You | You | Varies | We help |
| Design control | Very high, by you | High, by you, within templates | Depends | Built around your business |
| Google basics | You set up | You set up | Varies | Set up for you |
| Changes after launch | You make them | You make them | Depends on availability | We make them |
| Ads support | Separate | Separate | Usually separate | Available in-house |
| Cost structure | Subscription plans | Subscription plans | Usually project fee | From $30/month |
| Best for | Hands-on owners | Design-led DIY owners | Specific projects | Busy local service businesses |
How to decide
Ask yourself:
- Do I want to build and edit the site myself? If yes, Wix or Squarespace may be a good fit.
- Do I have time to write content and learn the Google basics? If not, having someone build it for you will likely save money in the long run.
- Is my main goal more calls, bookings and quote requests? If yes, a provider focused on local lead generation helps.
- Will I run ads? If yes, a website and ads planned together often perform better.
- Do I need an online store or custom software? If yes, look for a provider that specialises in that.
The short version
Wix and Squarespace are solid tools for owners who want to build and manage their own site. A freelancer can be a good fit for a specific project with the right person. Magnet Media suits local service businesses that want a professional site built around their services, starting from $30/month, with content help, Google basics and changes handled for them. Choose based on your time, skills and goals, not just price.
Quick answers
Is Magnet Media better than Wix or Squarespace?
It depends on what you want. Wix and Squarespace suit owners who want to build and edit the site themselves. Magnet Media suits local service businesses that want a professional site built and maintained for them, starting from $30/month.
Can I edit a Magnet Media website myself?
No. We make changes for you. You send us what you want updated and we take care of it, so the site stays fast and working properly.
Is a freelancer cheaper than Magnet Media?
Sometimes for a one-time build, but freelancers vary widely, and ongoing changes and support depend on their availability. Compare the total cost over a few years and what each includes.
Who is Magnet Media best for?
Local and small service businesses in Canada and the US, such as trades, home services and similar businesses, that want a fast, professional site that brings in calls and bookings.