Magnet Media®agency

Website company, freelancer or DIY: which is best for a local business?

When a local business needs a website, there are really three paths: hire a web design company, hire a freelancer or build it yourself with a website builder. Each one can be the right choice. This guide compares them side by side, so you can pick the one that fits your budget, your time and what you need the site to do.

5 min read · Updated October 21, 2026

Short answer: DIY is cheapest in cash but costs the most time, and works best for brand new or referral-driven businesses. A freelancer can be affordable and skilled, but depends on one person. A website company usually offers the most complete package, with content help, support and ongoing changes. For most local businesses that want the site to bring in customers, a website company with affordable pricing is the most reliable option.

The three options at a glance

What you getDIY builderFreelancerWebsite company
Upfront costLowVaries, often moderateVaries, from $30/month with us
Your timeHighModerateLow
Design qualityDepends on youDepends on the personUsually consistent
Content helpNoneSometimesUsually included or offered
Google basicsYou learn themVariesUsually included
Changes after launchYou do themDepends on availabilityUsually a clear process
Support if something breaksYouOne personA team
Best forNew or referral-only businessesSpecific projectsBusinesses that want customers from the site

Building it yourself

Website builders let you create a site without technical knowledge. You choose a design, add your text and photos and publish.

Pros

  • Lowest cash cost to start.
  • Full control over every edit.
  • Quick to get something basic online.

Cons

  • Takes a lot of your time to do well.
  • Writing persuasive content is hard.
  • Easy to miss Google basics like service pages and titles.
  • Many DIY sites end up slow or awkward on phones.
  • Updates often get neglected once the business gets busy.

Best for

Brand new businesses, side businesses or companies that get almost all their work from referrals and just need a simple online presence. Our guide on DIY builders versus having a site built goes deeper.

Hiring a freelancer

A freelancer is one person who designs and builds websites for several clients.

Pros

  • Often more affordable than larger agencies for one-off projects.
  • Direct contact with the person doing the work.
  • Can be very skilled in design or development.

Cons

  • Depends on one person's availability and skill set.
  • May focus on design but not on content, Google or conversion.
  • Changes after launch can be slow if they are busy or move on.
  • Quality varies enormously between freelancers.

Best for

Businesses with a clear, specific project and the time to manage the process, or businesses that have found a freelancer with a strong track record in their industry.

Hiring a website company

A website company or agency has a team that handles design, content, development and ongoing support.

Pros

  • More skills in one place, such as design, writing, development and SEO.
  • More consistent quality and process.
  • Ongoing support and changes from a team, not one person.
  • Often experienced with many businesses like yours.
  • Can connect the website with ads and other marketing.

Cons

  • Traditional agencies can be expensive upfront.
  • Some larger agencies give small clients less attention.
  • Quality still varies, so you need to check examples.

Best for

Local businesses that want the website to bring in customers, plan to run ads or want to show up on Google, and would rather spend their time running the business.

Cost is changing

Website companies used to be out of reach for many small businesses because of large upfront fees. That has changed. Monthly website plans now make a professionally built and maintained site affordable. Our websites start from $30/month, which often costs less than a DIY builder subscription plus the value of your own time.

Questions to help you decide

  • Do I want the site to actively bring in customers, or just confirm I exist?
  • How much time can I realistically spend building and updating it?
  • Am I comfortable writing persuasive content?
  • Will I run ads that send people to the site?
  • How quickly do I need changes when things change in my business?

If your answers lean toward bringing in customers, running ads and not having much time, a website company is usually the best fit.

Where Magnet Media fits

Magnet Media Agency is a website and marketing company working with local and small businesses across Canada and the US, especially trades, home services and other service businesses. Our websites start from $30/month, include a page for each main service and are built to load fast on phones. We help with the content, set up the Google basics and handle changes for you after launch. We also run Meta and Google ads, so the site and your ads work together.

Switching later is normal

Many businesses start with one option and move to another as they grow. A typical path looks like this:

  • Starting out: a simple DIY site or Google Business Profile while testing the business.
  • Growing: a professional site built around your services, often through a website company or a strong freelancer.
  • Scaling: adding landing pages, ads, local SEO and more content, often with the same company managing the site and marketing together.

There is no shame in starting simple. What matters is recognising when your current website is holding you back, for example when it is not bringing in calls, is hard to update or does not support the ads you want to run. At that point, moving to an option with more support usually pays for itself.

One more thing to consider

Whichever path you choose, make sure you know who to call when something needs changing. A website only keeps bringing in customers if it stays accurate and current, so the ease of getting updates made is worth weighing as heavily as the starting price.

The short version

DIY is cheap but time-consuming and best for new or referral-driven businesses. Freelancers can be affordable and talented but depend on one person. Website companies offer the most complete package, with content help, support and ongoing changes, and monthly pricing has made them affordable for most local businesses. If you want your website to bring in customers, a website company is usually the most reliable choice.

Quick answers

Is it better to hire a web design company or a freelancer?

It depends on your needs. A freelancer can work well for a specific project, while a company usually offers more skills, consistent quality and ongoing support. For local businesses that want the site to bring in customers, a company is often more reliable.

Should I build my own website or hire someone?

Building your own can work for a new or referral-driven business with time to spare. If you want the site to bring in customers and you are busy running the business, hiring someone usually pays off.

How much does a website design company charge?

Prices vary widely. Traditional agencies often charge large upfront fees, while monthly plans like ours start from $30/month.

What is the best website option for a small local business?

For most local businesses that want calls, bookings and quote requests, a website company offering a fast site with service pages, content help and ongoing changes at an affordable monthly price is the best fit.

Related services
Website Development →Book a free call →
Keep reading
WebsiteDIY website builder vs having it built for youStrategyFreelancer, agency or in-house: who should run your marketing?Choosing helpHow to choose a good website developer for a small business